top of page

Why Return to Sport After Upper Limb Injury Is Delayed

7 hours ago
11 min read

Return to sport after an upper limb injury is often slower than the healing of the tissues alone would explain, and in my experience part of the delay comes from the way rehabilitation is organised. I have worked in sport for more than 25 years, close to 19 of them with the UK Sports Institute, mostly in boxing, which is where my interest in the upper limb developed. For the last year I have been at the Inspire Institute of Sport in India, where judo, taekwondo, boxing, wrestling and many other sports train under the same roof, and the upper limb features prominently among the injuries. A recent example is a judoka who injured a shoulder, a joint that is exposed to trauma continuously in a sport with so much pulling. The question I ask in these situations is how to return the athlete in the best and most effective way. In this article I describe three habits of practice that, in my experience, delay that return: reliance on an exact diagnosis before anything is done, strict adherence to post-operative protocols, and the absence of a real plan with any sense of urgency.


Prognosis As Form Plus Function


When the aim is to estimate when someone will be back to activity, and eventually to sport, I like to work with a simple equation: prognosis equals form plus function. Form is the structure, which is essentially the diagnosis. Function is what the person can do. The two do not necessarily match, because they run on different time scales. Form follows physiological time scales, which are the ones we learned at university, for example how long a tendon, a capsule or a bone takes to heal. Function follows psychosocial time scales as well as biological ones, so I need to consider the psychology of the person, what is happening in their life and the commitments they have.

None of this means that I disregard form. Some pathologies, such as a scaphoid fracture or a detached biceps insertion, need a good diagnosis, and a few may need prompt surgery. In many other cases an exact diagnosis is not required, and the information about function is very usable. Many clinicians establish where the athlete currently is and start an intervention, which can become a hit-and-miss approach. I prefer to define the performance requirements of the sport, carry out a gap analysis against the current status, and direct the intervention at that gap.


Measuring Function Through Tissue Tolerance


Function means different things to different people. For an athlete I regard it as tissue tolerance, which I quantify through force and range of motion, with overall fitness in the background. Every sporting activity produces a certain amount of force in the tissues, and if overall fitness is not adequate, local findings matter less, because the athlete will struggle to train well in any case.

Range of motion is straightforward to measure, and mobile applications now allow wrist, elbow and shoulder measurements. I compare with a baseline if one exists, or with the opposite side if that side is uninjured, and obtain a percentage difference. For force, I distinguish it from strength. Strength is the physical property of the muscle, whereas force is the output, a physical quantity, and with dynamometers or even manual testing it is force that I test. To interpret injuries I use another simple equation: force equals strength minus pain.


Two bare arms resting on a treatment table with both elbows flexed at about 90 degrees, a goniometer on one elbow and a smartphone beside them, illustrating range of motion compared with the opposite side
Range of motion can be measured with a goniometer or a mobile application and compared with the opposite side, expressed as a percentage difference.

This equation guides what I do next. Suppose a judoka arrives two days after a shoulder injury, and dynamometry shows a painful 50% reduction in external rotation force. At this point the reduction is best explained by pain (Henriksen et al., 2011; Hodges and Tucker, 2011), and the strategy is pain management. Compare that with an athlete who has had shoulder problems for three months, has no pain during testing and shows a 30% difference. The limitation is no longer explained by pain and points to a lack of stress on the tissue, so the strategy moves towards improving the physical properties of the muscle.

The same measurements inform dosage. If it takes 30 kg of force to reproduce shoulder pain, I know that work at 25 to 28 kg is comfortable and that work at 32 to 35 kg is likely to provoke pain. In some conditions, such as chronic tendon problems, working with some pain can be useful (Silbernagel et al., 2007). Even so, I usually prefer to work well away from the threshold, and locating it is the purpose of the test.


Tools for Testing and Loading


I use handheld dynamometers, including versions attached to a belt to measure the elbow and shoulder, and fixed force frames that allow isometric testing. I use make tests, in which the athlete pushes against the device, and not break tests, so even in very acute stages athletes can perform the test on their own. In one boxer with a wrist injury the injured side recorded 7 on grip dynamometry against 53.5 on the other side, a deficit of about 87%. Over several weeks the deficit fell to 15%. That result suggests that the initial finding was pain inhibition from an acute injury and not weakness.

I also use dumbbells and gym equipment a great deal, because they give a numerical value, allow me to identify a threshold and serve as a way of loading. With weight as intensity and repetitions as volume, I can observe the response. For the shoulder I use a posterior cuff resistance test with the arm lifted horizontally, and a shorter lever biases the rotator cuff more, with concentric and eccentric work of the external rotators. The same exercises serve as tests and then as rehabilitation, and reverse curls test the wrist extensors and can also load tissues in athletes with elbow tendinopathy.

Kettlebells add closed and open kinetic chain options, again with numerical values: an athlete who manages 8 kilograms on the unaffected side and 4 on the affected side gives me objectivity as well as something to work towards. A weight-bearing scale offers another measure of loading capacity. As the athlete pushes down, I can read the force through the upper limb, note any symptoms, and test whether a strap or splint allows more force or simply greater comfort. Isokinetic dynamometry, which I have used throughout my career, is not something I use in the presence of pain, because simpler isometrics and dumbbells provide the same information more quickly. It becomes useful when pain is absent and I want to examine eccentric strength or behaviour at different speeds.


A taped hand pressing down on a digital platform scale on a bench in a strength and conditioning room, with kettlebells and a rack behind it, illustrating a numerical measure of upper limb loading
Pushing down on a weight-bearing scale gives a numerical reading of the loading capacity of the upper limb.

Post-Operative Protocols for Upper Limb Injury


The second cause of delay is strict adherence to protocols. After a shoulder operation such as a SLAP repair or a bone procedure, athletes typically spend four to six weeks in a sling and are told that return will take about six months. Prolonged immobilisation has consequences: the joint becomes stiff, much time goes into regaining mobility, and less time is left for developing force quality. Return may also be decided on manual testing by the surgeon, without reference to the strength requirements of the athlete, which increases the risk of re-injury.

Two athletes at the Inspire Institute of Sport illustrate the alternative. The first had an acromioclavicular joint injury that, on the Rockwood classification, required surgery (Beitzel et al., 2014). The advice was six weeks in a sling and a return in six months. We started weight-bearing testing two days after the operation, established what the athlete could do on one side as a percentage of the other, and began loading the joint with perturbation on a ball. The second athlete was a young judoka who had undergone repair for shoulder instability, and the advice was again six weeks in a sling and six months to return. We removed the sling completely at about five days, and she competed at three months. I began with closed kinetic chain exercises, because they allow good loading in a controlled position, and progressed to a combination of open and closed chain work, as is appropriate for a combat athlete. By three months we had used no manual therapy and no electrotherapy, only progressive loading and early range of motion.

The same reasoning applies to fractures. Two days after a radial styloid fracture, and with the cast still on, an athlete can load through the fingers with bands and perform isometrics against a wall. Absence of weight bearing does not mean absence of loading. I also try to remove the cast in a timely manner so that stiffness does not develop. Rather than a protocol, I describe this as a framework: move early. Early movement reduces the chance of muscle atrophy (Appell, 1990), reduces fear, lowers the chance of post-traumatic joint stiffness and reduces the need for adjunctive therapies such as aggressive manual therapy or complex electrotherapy. It also increases tissue tolerance and supports healing, because loading is one of the most natural stimuli for our tissues. Intensity is kept low at first, with a good deal of repetition and volume, and later intensity increases while frequency decreases. It also allows strength training to begin sooner, which either shortens the time scale or, for the same time scale, provides more preparation.


An athlete's forearm in a dark cast pressing the palm against a gym wall, with a resistance band on a rack behind, illustrating isometric loading with the cast still on after a wrist fracture
With the cast still on, loading is possible through the fingers with bands and through isometrics against a wall.

In my experience many of these protocols are not evidence-based, because many were created by surgeons, who do excellent work in surgery but have less experience of rehabilitation. People can be returned much faster by starting them early, building the load progressively to the point where they feel comfortable and are able to move.


Psychological Readiness


Psychological readiness is not only physical (Ardern et al., 2016), and it is often reduced to a questionnaire given at the end of rehabilitation, asking how the athlete feels. I think it needs more attention than that, and I try to ask what could be causing hesitation. In judo and wrestling, where loading in outer ranges is required, I use ball-based drills in the later stages of rehabilitation. They build local tolerance and quality, and they also show athletes that they can move in these ranges and feel well, which gives them confidence. I would not use them in the early stages of a significant injury.


A Plan With a Target and a Sense of Urgency


The third cause of delay is the absence of a plan. I often see no target event, meaning a training camp or a competition that the athlete needs to be ready for, from which the timeline can be worked out backwards. Starting rehabilitation and seeing how the athlete responds is not a plan. Rehabilitation is part of a plan, and the plan operates at macro, meso and micro levels. It begins with shared decision-making, in which the coaching team, the athlete and the support staff agree on how this athlete fits within the plan for the team.

For macroplanning I write down the phases and the number of weeks I expect each to take, and I extrapolate to a date by which the athlete should be fully returned. This is an estimate, but it draws on experience, knowledge of the research and discussion with colleagues. The macroplan is a skeleton, and mesoplanning, particularly with return to sport in mind, is where therapists struggle most. A boxer returning after an upper limb injury illustrates the point. First I identify the competition and its date. Then I ask how much preparation the boxer needs when fully fit, for example six weeks, and how long return to full training should take, for example four weeks. Working backwards, the athlete needs ten weeks in total, and I work back again to day zero, which may be the day after an operation. Within the microcycle, each day shows the volume, such as the number of rounds and the equipment used, and a percentage intensity, in this case 60 to 80%.

Because prognosis is form plus function, the estimate is checked as we go. If the plan assumed three weeks to reach full range, I ask whether that has been achieved, and the answer acts as an exit criterion for the next phase. The plan also has to take account of life events: if an athlete asks to take a holiday, I ask whether it fits the plan or hinders it, because the discussion is more honest when the plan is explicit.


Conclusion


I treat the person and not the scan. Treating a diagnosis is different from treating an athlete, and function is the more informative guide. Post-operative protocols are often not evidence-based, and in my experience loading early, and building to the point where the athlete is comfortable and able to move, returns people more quickly. When the injury is a fracture there is still an opportunity to load early, because no weight bearing is not the same as no loading, and a weight-bearing scale can be a useful tool. Finally, there must always be a plan with a target, because the target turns the many small decisions in rehabilitation into decisions with a purpose.


---


Frequently Asked Questions


Q: What does "prognosis equals form plus function" mean?

Form is the structure, essentially the diagnosis, and function is what the person can do. The two follow different time scales: form follows physiological healing times, whereas function follows psychosocial as well as biological time scales. Considering both allows a more useful estimate of return to activity than the diagnosis alone, although some pathologies, such as a scaphoid fracture or a detached biceps insertion, do need a good diagnosis.


Q: Why does force equal strength minus pain?

Strength is the physical property of the muscle, whereas force is the measured output. In an acutely injured athlete a reduction in force is best explained by pain (Henriksen et al., 2011; Hodges and Tucker, 2011), and the strategy is pain management. When the same deficit persists without pain, it points to a lack of stress on the tissue, and the strategy moves towards improving the physical properties of the muscle.


Q: Why use make tests and not break tests?

In a make test the athlete pushes against a fixed device or resistance, so even in very acute stages the athlete can perform the test alone, and side-to-side comparison gives a good indication of status. In a break test the examiner overcomes the effort of the athlete.


Q: Can an athlete load the limb after surgery or during a fracture?

Absence of weight bearing does not mean absence of loading. Two days after a radial styloid fracture, with the cast still on, an athlete can load through the fingers with bands and perform isometrics against a wall. Early movement reduces the chance of muscle atrophy (Appell, 1990), reduces fear and lowers the chance of post-traumatic joint stiffness.


Q: How is a return-to-sport plan built?

The plan starts from a target event, such as a competition, and works backwards. In the boxer example, six weeks of preparation plus four weeks to return to full training gave ten weeks in total, back to day zero, which may be the day after an operation. Exit criteria, such as a range of motion reached by a planned week, show whether the athlete can progress to the next phase.


  • Appell, H.-J. (1990) 'Muscular atrophy following immobilisation: a review', Sports Medicine, 10(1), pp. 42–58. doi:10.2165/00007256-199010010-00005.

  • Ardern, C.L., Glasgow, P., Schneiders, A., Witvrouw, E., Clarsen, B., Cools, A., Gojanovic, B., Griffin, S., Khan, K.M., Moksnes, H., Mutch, S.A., Phillips, N., Reurink, G., Sadler, R., Silbernagel, K.G., Thorborg, K., Wangensteen, A., Wilk, K.E. and Bizzini, M. (2016) '2016 Consensus statement on return to sport from the First World Congress in Sports Physical Therapy, Bern', British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(14), pp. 853–864. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2016-096278.

  • Beitzel, K., Mazzocca, A.D., Bak, K., Itoi, E., Kibler, W.B., Mirzayan, R., Imhoff, A.B., Calvo, E., Arce, G. and Shea, K. (2014) 'ISAKOS Upper Extremity Committee consensus statement on the need for diversification of the Rockwood classification for acromioclavicular joint injuries', Arthroscopy, 30(2), pp. 271–278. doi:10.1016/j.arthro.2013.11.005.

  • Henriksen, M., Rosager, S., Aaboe, J., Graven-Nielsen, T. and Bliddal, H. (2011) 'Experimental knee pain reduces muscle strength', The Journal of Pain, 12(4), pp. 460–467. doi:10.1016/j.jpain.2010.10.004.

  • Hodges, P.W. and Tucker, K. (2011) 'Moving differently in pain: a new theory to explain the adaptation to pain', Pain, 152(3 Suppl), pp. S90–S98. doi:10.1016/j.pain.2010.10.020.

  • Silbernagel, K.G., Thomeé, R., Eriksson, B.I. and Karlsson, J. (2007) 'Continued sports activity, using a pain-monitoring model, during rehabilitation in patients with Achilles tendinopathy: a randomized controlled study', American Journal of Sports Medicine, 35(6), pp. 897–906. doi:10.1177/0363546506298279.





headshot of Ian Gatt, head of physiotherapy at Inspire Institute of Sport

Ian has been a Sports Physiotherapist for over 25 years. As a globally recognised Upper Limb Injury Specialist, he has extensive experience at multiple Olympics and Commonwealth Games and supports various sporting organisations.

Ian is also the Cutman with team Anthony Joshua and other professional boxers, as well as a leading voice in health and performance strategies within the UK and Indian High Performance Systems.

Ian has a passion for teaching and delivers international educational workshops and webinars at conferences and on university programmes.

Comments


bottom of page